In Aug 2017 we submitted this modest proposal for Temple Way to address the missing link on this important route across the entrance to Temple Meads Station. We don’t feel the provision for walking and cycling on the redesigned Temple Meads / Temple Quarter Enterprise Zone are anywhere near adequate (Temple Greenways consultation).
The short response from the programme manager was “The idea you have put forward was considered in the design process for the Temple Circus scheme but we have chosen alternatives routes to improve for cyclists.”
The longer version went:
Works to the Temple Circus gyratory, Temple Gate and Bath Bridges are underway and are due for completion by Autumn 2018. More information on the works, including plans, can be found on the BTQEZ website. Included in the Temple Circus scheme are significant improvements to cycle routes through the area, including, wherever possible, segregated cycle routes on the key desire lines. We have also sought to future proof the scheme as much as possible in terms of supporting and connecting to the redevelopment of Temple Meads Station. As indicated in the Spatial Framework for the Enterprise Zone (also available on the BTQEZ website), there is opportunity for significantly improved and increased cycle parking for the station to be provided on the north side adjacent to an improved northern entrance. This then changes the routes by which cyclists will approach the station.
Here’s our proposal text:
Temple Way currently carries some 1,700 cycle movements per day between Temple Circus and Station Approach. However, conditions for the large numbers of cycle journeys between Temple Meads and south Bristol are far less satisfactory. Bristol Cycling have identi ed how a modest investment could make a major di erence to all those wishing to cycle to the Temple Meads / Temple Quarter Enterprise Zone area from the south.
A missing piece of key infrastructure
The short distance between the Temple Way – Station Approach junction and Bath Bridges. Currently the area has benefitted from a series of new cycle infrastructure, including:
- Clarence Rd cycleway – linking Bath Bridges with Redcli e roundabout
- Cattle Market Rd – new Cycling Ambition Fund segregated path unlocking part of TQEZ earmarked for development by the University of Bristol
- Brunel Mile – walking and cycling route linking Temple Circus with Queen Square
- Existing shared paths linking
Temple Circus with the Temple Way – Station Approach junction.
Despite the large number of cycle journeys on Temple Way, there are currently no continuous cycle facilities linking Temple Meads with Bath Bridges gyratory. Existing conditions are unpleasant, with a six lane dual carriageway separating the western from the eastern sides of Temple Way. On the eastern side, many instances of cyclists on the pavement can be observed, interfering with pedestrians and bus passengers which indicates the perceived danger. Many of these southbound cyclists then face a three or four stage crossing to reach the protected cycleway on Clarence Road – a highly inconvenient arrangement.
A fully segregated cycleway is proposed for this section by taking advantage of the following factors:
- Need to create protected cycleway
- Need to avoid conflicts with pedestrians
- Opportunity of ‘dead’ space within the grass/paved strip and central reservation
- Opportunity due to no right turn into Temple Way – to create ‘with ow’ arrangements for cycles
The proposal is illustrated on the following diagram:
The proposal is entirely consistent with the Temple Quarter Enterprise Zone Sustainable Mobility Plan which notes:
- Key weaknesses: “Car dominated road layout creates major physical barriers and a oor environment for walking and cycling”; Good connections by bike from north and west but not south and east – this proposal directly addresses the main desire line on the eastern side of Temple Way
- “Segregated cycle lanes where feasible” score highly in SUMP sense check – this proposal is for segregated lanes free from the issues which occur with shared space. Recently pedestrian barriers have been introduced on Friary shared space due to con icts between pedestrians, cyclists and other vehicles.
University of Bristol
The University of Bristol Temple Quay Masterplan is ideally located to take advantage of this proposal, providing direct access to the site from Cattle Market Road towards the city centre via Victoria Street
The following points illustrate the advantages of the proposal:
- Provides a continuous cycle-only route, removing con icts with pedestrians
- No impact on signal timings at Station Approach junction – separate signal head for cycles linked to the Temple Way ows. Alternative of signalised crossing at the Bath Rd exit onto Temple Way would likely create greater delays to tra c
- No impact on Bath Bridges signals – crossing from Temple Way to the central island with ow
- Can be joined by cyclists existing Station Approach either northbound or southbound
- Easy access for crossing to Cattle Market Road at existing signals
- Reduces one crossing stage for cycles from Temple Circus to Clarence Road
The following engineering constraint is noted:
- May require lane narrowing or reduction from 3 lanes to 2 on northbound Temple Way near Victoria House in order to accommodate 3m two-way cycleway; however this is not considered a major constraint in terms of impact on tra c ow – the main constraint on tra c capacity appears to be the existing (soon to be remodelled) junction of Temple Way with Redcli e Way.